Discuss the ethical issues concerning the use of drugs to improve performance in sport. (5 marks)
--- 15 WORK AREA LINES (style=lined) ---
Show Answers Only
Issues against drug use
- [P] Performance-enhancing drugs undermine fair competition.
- [E] Drug users gain an unfair advantage over clean athletes, so results no longer reflect talent, training and effort.
- [Ev] For example, Lance Armstrong was stripped of his seven Tour de France titles in 2012 and later admitted to using EPO and other banned methods.
- [L] This shows drug use breaches the spirit of sport and damages its integrity.
- [P] Drug use places athletes’ health at serious risk and raises concerns about coercion and duty of care.
- [E] Anabolic steroids can cause heart and liver damage, and EPO thickens the blood, increasing the risk of stroke. Athletes may be pressured by coaches, officials or competitors to accept these risks just to remain competitive.
- [Ev] For example, in East Germany’s state-run doping program, athletes, many of them teenagers, were given anabolic steroids without being told what they were, and many suffered lasting health damage.
- [L] This shows drug use can remove athletes’ ability to give informed consent, and it sends a harmful message to young people who see elite athletes as role models.
Issues for drug use
- [P] Some argue athletes should have the right to make decisions about their own bodies.
- [E] Supporters claim legal, medically supervised use would be safer than secret use and would create a level playing field.
- [Ev] Inconsistent testing between countries already creates an uneven playing field, and therapeutic use exemptions (TUEs) allow some athletes to use banned substances for medical reasons, blurring the line between treatment and enhancement.
- [L] However, most agree the risks to health and fairness outweigh these arguments, which is why WADA continues to ban performance-enhancing drugs.
Show Worked Solution
Issues against drug use
- [P] Performance-enhancing drugs undermine fair competition.
- [E] Drug users gain an unfair advantage over clean athletes, so results no longer reflect talent, training and effort.
- [Ev] For example, Lance Armstrong was stripped of his seven Tour de France titles in 2012 and later admitted to using EPO and other banned methods.
- [L] This shows drug use breaches the spirit of sport and damages its integrity.
- [P] Drug use places athletes’ health at serious risk and raises concerns about coercion and duty of care.
- [E] Anabolic steroids can cause heart and liver damage, and EPO thickens the blood, increasing the risk of stroke. Athletes may be pressured by coaches, officials or competitors to accept these risks just to remain competitive.
- [Ev] For example, in East Germany’s state-run doping program, athletes, many of them teenagers, were given anabolic steroids without being told what they were, and many suffered lasting health damage.
- [L] This shows drug use can remove athletes’ ability to give informed consent, and it sends a harmful message to young people who see elite athletes as role models.
Issues for drug use
- [P] Some argue athletes should have the right to make decisions about their own bodies.
- [E] Supporters claim legal, medically supervised use would be safer than secret use and would create a level playing field.
- [Ev] Inconsistent testing between countries already creates an uneven playing field, and therapeutic use exemptions (TUEs) allow some athletes to use banned substances for medical reasons, blurring the line between treatment and enhancement.
- [L] However, most agree the risks to health and fairness outweigh these arguments, which is why WADA continues to ban performance-enhancing drugs.