SmarterEd

Aussie Maths & Science Teachers: Save your time with SmarterEd

  • Login
  • Get Help
  • About

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 223

Critically analyse the effectiveness of carbohydrate loading for different types of athletic events.   (8 marks)

--- 24 WORK AREA LINES (style=lined) ---

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer

Overview Statement:

Carbohydrate loading effectiveness varies significantly with event duration, showing a clear relationship between time demands and glycogen requirements.

Endurance Events (Extended Duration):

  • Carbohydrate loading proves essential for events exceeding ninety minutes because glycogen depletion becomes the primary performance limiter.
  • The loading process maximises muscle glycogen stores through increased intake while tapering training, which directly addresses the aerobic system’s heavy reliance on this fuel.
  • This relationship demonstrates that loading effectiveness increases with event duration, as longer events depend more heavily on maximised glycogen availability.
  • Therefore, marathon and triathlon performances benefit substantially from proper loading protocols.

Shorter Duration Events:

  • Events under ninety minutes show minimal benefit from loading because normal glycogen stores adequately support these activities.
  • Regular daily carbohydrate intake provides sufficient fuel without special protocols, as glycogen depletion rarely occurs during shorter efforts.
  • This reveals that loading becomes unnecessary when event duration doesn’t threaten glycogen availability.

Ultra-Endurance Events:

  • Ultra-events require loading but also demand additional strategies because even maximised stores deplete during extreme duration activities.
  • The relationship shows that loading provides only initial preparation, while continuous carbohydrate consumption during events becomes equally critical.
  • This indicates that loading effectiveness has limits for events where duration exceeds glycogen storage capacity.

Implications:

  • This analysis reveals that carbohydrate loading effectiveness directly correlates with event duration and energy system demands.
  • Athletes must match loading strategies to their specific event rather than applying universal protocols.

Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

Overview Statement:

Carbohydrate loading effectiveness varies significantly with event duration, showing a clear relationship between time demands and glycogen requirements.

Endurance Events (Extended Duration):

  • Carbohydrate loading proves essential for events exceeding ninety minutes because glycogen depletion becomes the primary performance limiter.
  • The loading process maximises muscle glycogen stores through increased intake while tapering training, which directly addresses the aerobic system’s heavy reliance on this fuel.
  • This relationship demonstrates that loading effectiveness increases with event duration, as longer events depend more heavily on maximised glycogen availability.
  • Therefore, marathon and triathlon performances benefit substantially from proper loading protocols.

Shorter Duration Events:

  • Events under ninety minutes show minimal benefit from loading because normal glycogen stores adequately support these activities.
  • Regular daily carbohydrate intake provides sufficient fuel without special protocols, as glycogen depletion rarely occurs during shorter efforts.
  • This reveals that loading becomes unnecessary when event duration doesn’t threaten glycogen availability.

Ultra-Endurance Events:

  • Ultra-events require loading but also demand additional strategies because even maximised stores deplete during extreme duration activities.
  • The relationship shows that loading provides only initial preparation, while continuous carbohydrate consumption during events becomes equally critical.
  • This indicates that loading effectiveness has limits for events where duration exceeds glycogen storage capacity.

Implications:

  • This analysis reveals that carbohydrate loading effectiveness directly correlates with event duration and energy system demands.
  • Athletes must match loading strategies to their specific event rather than applying universal protocols.

Filed Under: Nutrition and energy systems Tagged With: Band 5, Band 6, smc-5529-15-Anaerobic v aerobic

Copyright © 2014–2025 SmarterEd.com.au · Log in