SmarterEd

Aussie Maths & Science Teachers: Save your time with SmarterEd

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 451

A student conducted an 8-week investigation on how aerobic training affects resting heart rate, recording measurements every 2 weeks. Assess the most appropriate ways to present these findings and draw conclusions that accurately reflect the changes observed.   (5 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer 

  • A line graph showing the average resting heart rate at each 2-week interval would visually demonstrate the pattern of change over time, making it clear whether improvements were steady or occurred primarily during specific periods.
  • Including individual data points or separate lines for each participant would show the range of responses, allowing conclusions about consistency of effects across different individuals.
  • Calculating and presenting the percentage change in resting heart rate would provide context about the magnitude of improvement, helping to determine whether the changes were significant enough to be meaningful.
  • Comparing the findings to expected changes based on research would allow for conclusions about whether the training program was effective relative to established norms.
  • Acknowledging limitations such as sample size and factors that might have influenced results (like participant adherence to the program) ensures honest and realistic conclusions about the observed changes.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer 

  • A line graph showing the average resting heart rate at each 2-week interval would visually demonstrate the pattern of change over time, making it clear whether improvements were steady or occurred primarily during specific periods.
  • Including individual data points or separate lines for each participant would show the range of responses, allowing conclusions about consistency of effects across different individuals.
  • Calculating and presenting the percentage change in resting heart rate would provide context about the magnitude of improvement, helping to determine whether the changes were significant enough to be meaningful.
  • Comparing the findings to expected changes based on research would allow for conclusions about whether the training program was effective relative to established norms.
  • Acknowledging limitations such as sample size and factors that might have influenced results (like participant adherence to the program) ensures honest and realistic conclusions about the observed changes.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 450

Explain how you could use physiological data collected during an aerobic training investigation to draw valid conclusions about the relationship between training intensity and improvement in aerobic capacity.   (4 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer 

  • Calculate the percentage improvement in aerobic capacity measures (VO₂ max, lactate threshold) for participants training at different intensity zones (low, moderate, high) to determine which intensity produces optimal adaptations.
  • Analyse heart rate data during training sessions to verify that participants maintained their assigned training intensities, ensuring conclusions about intensity-related effects are based on actual training loads experienced.
  • Examine whether a dose-response relationship exists by plotting training intensity against improvements, determining if benefits increase linearly with intensity or if there’s an optimal range beyond which returns diminish.
  • Control for and account for confounding variables such as training volume and frequency when analysing the intensity relationship, ensuring conclusions specifically isolate the effect of intensity rather than other training factors.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer 

  • Calculate the percentage improvement in aerobic capacity measures (VO₂ max, lactate threshold) for participants training at different intensity zones (low, moderate, high) to determine which intensity produces optimal adaptations.
  • Analyse heart rate data during training sessions to verify that participants maintained their assigned training intensities, ensuring conclusions about intensity-related effects are based on actual training loads experienced.
  • Examine whether a dose-response relationship exists by plotting training intensity against improvements, determining if benefits increase linearly with intensity or if there’s an optimal range beyond which returns diminish.
  • Control for and account for confounding variables such as training volume and frequency when analysing the intensity relationship, ensuring conclusions specifically isolate the effect of intensity rather than other training factors.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 449

Critically analyse how different presentation methods could affect the interpretation of findings from an investigation comparing the effects of continuous versus interval aerobic training on VO₂ max improvement.   (6 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer 

  • Bar graphs showing average improvements could visually emphasise differences between training methods, but without error bars might exaggerate small differences that aren’t statistically significant.
  • Scatter plots showing individual data points would transparently reveal the distribution of responses in both groups, preventing misinterpretation of averages that might mask substantial overlap between methods.
  • Line graphs tracking changes over time would effectively show the rate of improvement for each method, revealing whether one method produces faster initial gains versus greater long-term improvements.
  • Line graphs tracking changes over time would effectively show the rate of improvement for each method, revealing whether one method produces faster initial gains versus greater long-term improvements.
  • Using percentage change rather than absolute values could alter interpretation by normalising improvements relative to baseline, potentially favoring the method that works better for initially less-fit individuals.
  • Selectively highlighting specific time points or variables where differences are greatest could create bias toward one method, whereas comprehensive data presentation with effect sizes would provide a more balanced interpretation of relative effectiveness.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer 

  • Bar graphs showing average improvements could visually emphasise differences between training methods, but without error bars might exaggerate small differences that aren’t statistically significant.
  • Scatter plots showing individual data points would transparently reveal the distribution of responses in both groups, preventing misinterpretation of averages that might mask substantial overlap between methods.
  • Line graphs tracking changes over time would effectively show the rate of improvement for each method, revealing whether one method produces faster initial gains versus greater long-term improvements.
  • Line graphs tracking changes over time would effectively show the rate of improvement for each method, revealing whether one method produces faster initial gains versus greater long-term improvements.
  • Using percentage change rather than absolute values could alter interpretation by normalising improvements relative to baseline, potentially favoring the method that works better for initially less-fit individuals.
  • Selectively highlighting specific time points or variables where differences are greatest could create bias toward one method, whereas comprehensive data presentation with effect sizes would provide a more balanced interpretation of relative effectiveness.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 448

A student investigated the impact of a 4-week aerobic training program on participants' recovery heart rates. Describe how the student could effectively present their findings to demonstrate individual variability in training responses.   (3 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer 

  • Individual line graphs could be presented showing each participant’s recovery heart rate profile before and after training, highlighting the unique magnitude and pattern of improvement for each person.
  • Box plots could display the distribution of recovery heart rates at different time points, visually demonstrating the range and variability of responses while showing the overall group trend.
  • A table organising participants into responder categories (high, moderate, low) based on percentage improvement in recovery heart rate would effectively quantify and categorise individual variability while maintaining data organisation.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer 

  • Individual line graphs could be presented showing each participant’s recovery heart rate profile before and after training, highlighting the unique magnitude and pattern of improvement for each person.
  • Box plots could display the distribution of recovery heart rates at different time points, visually demonstrating the range and variability of responses while showing the overall group trend.
  • A table organising participants into responder categories (high, moderate, low) based on percentage improvement in recovery heart rate would effectively quantify and categorise individual variability while maintaining data organisation.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 447

Compare the advantages and disadvantages of using tables versus graphs when presenting findings from an investigation on heart rate recovery after aerobic training.   (4 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer 

  • Tables provide precise numerical data allowing for exact comparisons of heart rate values at specific time points, whereas graphs sacrifice some numerical precision for visual pattern recognition.
  • Graphs effectively demonstrate trends in heart rate recovery over time, making the rate and pattern of recovery immediately visible, while tables require mental processing to identify these patterns.
  • Tables can efficiently present multiple variables simultaneously (resting heart rate, maximum heart rate, recovery time) in an organised format, whereas multiple graphs might be needed to show the same range of data.
  • Graphs are generally more accessible to audiences without statistical expertise, facilitating broader understanding of findings, while detailed tables may require greater numerical literacy.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer 

  • Tables provide precise numerical data allowing for exact comparisons of heart rate values at specific time points, whereas graphs sacrifice some numerical precision for visual pattern recognition.
  • Graphs effectively demonstrate trends in heart rate recovery over time, making the rate and pattern of recovery immediately visible, while tables require mental processing to identify these patterns.
  • Tables can efficiently present multiple variables simultaneously (resting heart rate, maximum heart rate, recovery time) in an organised format, whereas multiple graphs might be needed to show the same range of data.
  • Graphs are generally more accessible to audiences without statistical expertise, facilitating broader understanding of findings, while detailed tables may require greater numerical literacy.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 446

Evaluate the extent to which physiological data collected during a 6-week aerobic training study can be used to draw conclusions about long-term adaptations to aerobic exercise.   (4 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer 

  • A 6-week study can capture initial improvements in heart rate and recovery time, but may not show the complete range of cardiovascular benefits that develop over longer periods.
  • Short-term studies show direction of change but cannot accurately predict whether improvements will continue at the same rate, plateau, or progress differently over extended periods.
  • Individual differences in response to training become more apparent over time, meaning a 6-week study might not fully represent the variety of adaptation patterns.
  • The principle of diminishing returns suggests that the rapid improvements often seen in short-term studies typically slow down over longer periods, limiting the ability to make direct long-term projections.
  • A 6-week timeframe provides valid information about immediate responses to aerobic training, but conclusions about long-term effects should be presented with appropriate caution about sustainability and continued progression.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer 

  • A 6-week study can capture initial improvements in heart rate and recovery time, but may not show the complete range of cardiovascular benefits that develop over longer periods.
  • Short-term studies show direction of change but cannot accurately predict whether improvements will continue at the same rate, plateau, or progress differently over extended periods.
  • Individual differences in response to training become more apparent over time, meaning a 6-week study might not fully represent the variety of adaptation patterns.
  • The principle of diminishing returns suggests that the rapid improvements often seen in short-term studies typically slow down over longer periods, limiting the ability to make direct long-term projections.
  • A 6-week timeframe provides valid information about immediate responses to aerobic training, but conclusions about long-term effects should be presented with appropriate caution about sustainability and continued progression.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 445

Explain why it is important to acknowledge limitations when presenting the findings of a physiological investigation on aerobic training.   (3 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer 

  • Acknowledging limitations demonstrates scientific integrity by recognising potential factors that could affect the validity of results, such as sample size constraints or measurement errors.
  • Identifying limitations provides context for interpreting findings, preventing overgeneralisation of conclusions beyond what the data can reasonably support.
  • Recognising limitations creates opportunities for improvement in future investigations by highlighting specific methodological aspects that could be strengthened.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer 

  • Acknowledging limitations demonstrates scientific integrity by recognising potential factors that could affect the validity of results, such as sample size constraints or measurement errors.
  • Identifying limitations provides context for interpreting findings, preventing overgeneralisation of conclusions beyond what the data can reasonably support.
  • Recognising limitations creates opportunities for improvement in future investigations by highlighting specific methodological aspects that could be strengthened.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 444

Analyse how the presentation of data collected during a 12-week aerobic training investigation can influence the conclusions drawn about improvements in cardiovascular efficiency.   (6 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer 

  • Presenting data as percentage change from baseline rather than raw numbers highlights relative improvements, allowing for more meaningful comparisons between participants with different starting fitness levels.
  • Including both average group results and individual case studies provides a balanced view of overall trends while acknowledging that not all participants respond to aerobic training at the same rate or magnitude.
  • Displaying progressive measurements (at 4, 8, and 12 weeks) rather than just pre/post data reveals the timeline of adaptations, showing whether improvements occur steadily or plateau at certain points.
  • Comparing multiple cardiovascular measurements (resting heart rate, recovery time, blood pressure) creates a comprehensive picture of efficiency improvements rather than relying on a single measure that might not tell the complete story.
  • Using clear visuals like line graphs with consistent scales prevents misinterpretation of the magnitude of improvements, ensuring conclusions accurately reflect the actual physiological changes observed.
  • Separating data by relevant participant characteristics (age groups, initial fitness levels) allows for more precise conclusions about which populations might benefit most from similar aerobic training programs.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer 

  • Presenting data as percentage change from baseline rather than raw numbers highlights relative improvements, allowing for more meaningful comparisons between participants with different starting fitness levels.
  • Including both average group results and individual case studies provides a balanced view of overall trends while acknowledging that not all participants respond to aerobic training at the same rate or magnitude.
  • Displaying progressive measurements (at 4, 8, and 12 weeks) rather than just pre/post data reveals the timeline of adaptations, showing whether improvements occur steadily or plateau at certain points.
  • Comparing multiple cardiovascular measurements (resting heart rate, recovery time, blood pressure) creates a comprehensive picture of efficiency improvements rather than relying on a single measure that might not tell the complete story.
  • Using clear visuals like line graphs with consistent scales prevents misinterpretation of the magnitude of improvements, ensuring conclusions accurately reflect the actual physiological changes observed.
  • Separating data by relevant participant characteristics (age groups, initial fitness levels) allows for more precise conclusions about which populations might benefit most from similar aerobic training programs.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 443

Describe TWO methods for presenting findings from a physiological investigation that would effectively communicate the relationship between training intensity and oxygen consumption.   (4 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer – Any 2 of the following

  • A scatter plot with a line of best fit would effectively present the relationship between training intensity (x-axis) and oxygen consumption (y-axis), visually demonstrating the correlation and allowing for identification of the aerobic threshold where oxygen consumption increases disproportionately to intensity.
  • Tables organising data by intensity zones (low, moderate, high) with corresponding average oxygen consumption values would allow for clear numerical comparison across intensity levels and could include standard deviations to show variability within each intensity zone.
  • Line graphs showing oxygen consumption over time at different intensity levels could effectively display how oxygen uptake kinetics change based on exercise intensity, particularly highlighting differences in steady-state achievement and oxygen deficit at different intensities.
  • Heat maps could represent individual participant responses across various intensity levels, effectively visualising both group trends and individual variations in oxygen consumption responses to increasing training loads.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer – Any 2 of the following

  • A scatter plot with a line of best fit would effectively present the relationship between training intensity (x-axis) and oxygen consumption (y-axis), visually demonstrating the correlation and allowing for identification of the aerobic threshold where oxygen consumption increases disproportionately to intensity.
  • Tables organising data by intensity zones (low, moderate, high) with corresponding average oxygen consumption values would allow for clear numerical comparison across intensity levels and could include standard deviations to show variability within each intensity zone.
  • Line graphs showing oxygen consumption over time at different intensity levels could effectively display how oxygen uptake kinetics change based on exercise intensity, particularly highlighting differences in steady-state achievement and oxygen deficit at different intensities.
  • Heat maps could represent individual participant responses across various intensity levels, effectively visualising both group trends and individual variations in oxygen consumption responses to increasing training loads.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 442

Outline the purpose of including a visual representation of data when presenting findings from an investigation on physiological responses to aerobic training.   (3 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer

  • Visual representations such as graphs quickly communicate patterns in physiological data that might not be apparent in numerical tables.
  • Visuals allow for easier comparison of pre-training and post-training measurements, highlighting the magnitude of physiological adaptations.
  • Appropriate visual aids enhance audience understanding, particularly when presenting complex relationships between variables such as heart rate recovery time and training duration.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • Visual representations such as graphs quickly communicate patterns in physiological data that might not be apparent in numerical tables.
  • Visuals allow for easier comparison of pre-training and post-training measurements, highlighting the magnitude of physiological adaptations.
  • Appropriate visual aids enhance audience understanding, particularly when presenting complex relationships between variables such as heart rate recovery time and training duration.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 441 MC

When presenting findings from an investigation on the physiological responses to aerobic training, which of the following would be considered a limitation of the study?

  1. Using a control group who did not participate in the training program
  2. Testing participants' aerobic capacity before and after the training program
  3. Recording heart rate, blood pressure, and perceived exertion during exercise
  4. Having a small sample size of only 5 participants
Show Answers Only

Show Worked Solution

Consider Option D: Having a small sample size of only 5 participants

  • A small sample size is a valid limitation that restricts the generalisability of findings and statistical power.

Other Options:

  • A is incorrect: Using a control group is a strength, not a limitation, of an experimental design.
  • B is incorrect: Testing before and after the program is appropriate methodology, not a limitation.
  • C is incorrect: Recording multiple physiological measures provides more comprehensive data, making it a strength rather than a limitation.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 440 MC

A student investigating the effect of aerobic training on VO₂ max collected data from 10 participants before and after an 8-week training program. When drawing conclusions, which of the following would be most important to consider?

  1. Comparing the data with the general population's average VO₂ max
  2. The brand of equipment used to measure VO₂ max
  3. Statistical significance of the observed changes
  4. The participants' previous exercise experience
Show Answers Only

Show Worked Solution

Consider Option C: Statistical significance of the observed changes

  • Statistical significance determines whether the observed changes are likely due to the training program rather than random chance, which is crucial for valid conclusions.

Other Options:

  • A is incorrect: Comparing to population averages doesn’t directly address the investigation question about the effect of the specific training program.
  • B is incorrect: While equipment quality matters for data collection, it’s not the most important factor when drawing conclusions from already collected data.
  • D is incorrect: While previous exercise experience might be relevant as a variable to control, it’s not the most important factor when determining if the changes observed were meaningful.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 439 MC

Which of the following is the most appropriate method for presenting findings from a physiological investigation on heart rate recovery after aerobic training?

  1. A pie chart displaying participants' ages
  2. A line graph showing heart rate changes over time
  3. A list of individual participant names and their maximum heart rates
  4. A bar graph comparing average heart rates before and after training
Show Answers Only

Show Worked Solution

Consider Option B: A line graph showing heart rate changes over time

  • A line graph effectively shows changes over time, which is essential for displaying heart rate recovery patterns after aerobic training.

Other Options:

  • A is incorrect: A pie chart is suitable for showing proportions within a whole, not for displaying physiological changes over time.
  • C is incorrect: A list of names and maximum heart rates doesn’t visually represent patterns or relationships in the data.
  • D is incorrect: A bar graph is better for comparing discrete categories rather than continuous changes over time that occur during recovery.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 438

After conducting a pilot study on aerobic training and stress management in Year 11 students, a researcher found inconsistent results using a single data collection method.

Critically analyse which combination of data collection methods (observation, survey, and/or interview) would provide the most valid and reliable data for a full-scale investigation into this topic. Justify your response with specific examples of how each method would be implemented.   (8 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer

  • A combination of surveys, observation, and selective interviews would provide the most comprehensive data, as each method addresses different aspects of the relationship between aerobic training and stress management.
  • Surveys using validated tools like the Perceived Stress Scale should be administered pre-, mid-, and post-program to quantify changes in perceived stress levels, providing standardised numerical data that can be statistically analysed to identify trends across the participant group.
  • Direct observation during standardized stress tests (such as timed cognitive tasks) before and after the training program would provide objective physiological data through measuring visible stress responses like sweating, fidgeting, or facial expressions, complementing the subjective survey data.
  • Physiological measurements could be incorporated into observation sessions by recording vital signs like heart rate variability and blood pressure during stress tests, providing objective indicators of the body’s stress response that participants might not be consciously aware of.
  • Semi-structured interviews with a representative sample of participants showing varying degrees of improvement would explore the mechanisms behind individual differences, potentially revealing why some students benefited more than others from the aerobic training.
  • Interviews would also allow exploration of how participants applied stress management techniques learned through aerobic training to real-life situations outside the program, providing ecological validity that laboratory measurements cannot capture.
  • This triangulated approach compensates for the weaknesses of each individual method – surveys might be affected by social desirability bias, observations might miss internal experiences, and interviews alone might not provide generalizable data.
  • Implementation should include proper sequencing of methods, with surveys and observations conducted at consistent intervals throughout the program, and interviews conducted at the conclusion to prevent interview questions from influencing survey responses or observed behaviors.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • A combination of surveys, observation, and selective interviews would provide the most comprehensive data, as each method addresses different aspects of the relationship between aerobic training and stress management.
  • Surveys using validated tools like the Perceived Stress Scale should be administered pre-, mid-, and post-program to quantify changes in perceived stress levels, providing standardised numerical data that can be statistically analysed to identify trends across the participant group.
  • Direct observation during standardized stress tests (such as timed cognitive tasks) before and after the training program would provide objective physiological data through measuring visible stress responses like sweating, fidgeting, or facial expressions, complementing the subjective survey data.
  • Physiological measurements could be incorporated into observation sessions by recording vital signs like heart rate variability and blood pressure during stress tests, providing objective indicators of the body’s stress response that participants might not be consciously aware of.
  • Semi-structured interviews with a representative sample of participants showing varying degrees of improvement would explore the mechanisms behind individual differences, potentially revealing why some students benefited more than others from the aerobic training.
  • Interviews would also allow exploration of how participants applied stress management techniques learned through aerobic training to real-life situations outside the program, providing ecological validity that laboratory measurements cannot capture.
  • This triangulated approach compensates for the weaknesses of each individual method – surveys might be affected by social desirability bias, observations might miss internal experiences, and interviews alone might not provide generalizable data.
  • Implementation should include proper sequencing of methods, with surveys and observations conducted at consistent intervals throughout the program, and interviews conducted at the conclusion to prevent interview questions from influencing survey responses or observed behaviors.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 437

A student is designing an investigation to examine how a high-intensity interval training program affects recovery time and psychological wellbeing in adolescents.

Evaluate the strengths and limitations of using a combination of observation and interviews as data collection methods for this investigation.   (6 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer

  • Observation provides objective measurements of recovery time through visible physiological indicators (like heart rate return to baseline and normalised breathing rate), allowing for precise quantitative data about physical adaptations to training.
  • However, observation has limitations for measuring psychological wellbeing as many aspects of mental health are internal states that cannot be directly observed, potentially missing important data about participants’ experiences.
  • Interviews provide rich, detailed information about participants’ psychological experiences during and after training, including unexpected benefits or challenges that might not be captured through predetermined measurement tools.
  • Interviews can explore the relationship between observed physical recovery and perceived mental wellbeing, helping to establish connections between physiological and psychological adaptations to training.
  • A significant limitation of interviews is potential response bias, as participants might provide answers they believe the researcher wants to hear rather than accurately reporting their experiences.
  • Using both methods together creates complementary data sets that address each other’s weaknesses – observations provide objective measurements of recovery while interviews capture subjective experiences of wellbeing, creating a more comprehensive understanding of training effects.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • Observation provides objective measurements of recovery time through visible physiological indicators (like heart rate return to baseline and normalised breathing rate), allowing for precise quantitative data about physical adaptations to training.
  • However, observation has limitations for measuring psychological wellbeing as many aspects of mental health are internal states that cannot be directly observed, potentially missing important data about participants’ experiences.
  • Interviews provide rich, detailed information about participants’ psychological experiences during and after training, including unexpected benefits or challenges that might not be captured through predetermined measurement tools.
  • Interviews can explore the relationship between observed physical recovery and perceived mental wellbeing, helping to establish connections between physiological and psychological adaptations to training.
  • A significant limitation of interviews is potential response bias, as participants might provide answers they believe the researcher wants to hear rather than accurately reporting their experiences.
  • Using both methods together creates complementary data sets that address each other’s weaknesses – observations provide objective measurements of recovery while interviews capture subjective experiences of wellbeing, creating a more comprehensive understanding of training effects.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 436

A student wants to investigate the effects of a 10-week aerobic training program on perceived exertion levels during standardized exercise tasks.

Outline ONE appropriate data collection method for this investigation and explain why it would be suitable.   (3 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer

  • A survey using the Rate of Perceived Exertion (RPE) scale would be an appropriate data collection method as it provides a standardised numerical rating of subjective exertion levels that can be administered before, during, and after exercise tasks.
  • This method is suitable because perceived exertion is a subjective experience that cannot be directly observed but can be quantified through structured self-reporting, allowing participants to communicate how hard they feel they are working during the exercise tasks.
  • The RPE scale survey would enable consistent measurement across all participants and across multiple time points, making it possible to track changes in perceived exertion over the 10-week training program and identify patterns within the data.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • A survey using the Rate of Perceived Exertion (RPE) scale would be an appropriate data collection method as it provides a standardised numerical rating of subjective exertion levels that can be administered before, during, and after exercise tasks.
  • This method is suitable because perceived exertion is a subjective experience that cannot be directly observed but can be quantified through structured self-reporting, allowing participants to communicate how hard they feel they are working during the exercise tasks.
  • The RPE scale survey would enable consistent measurement across all participants and across multiple time points, making it possible to track changes in perceived exertion over the 10-week training program and identify patterns within the data.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 435 MC

A student is investigating how a 6-week aerobic training program affects participants' motivation to exercise. Which data collection method would provide the most comprehensive understanding of changes in motivation?

  1. Pre-post interviews asking open-ended questions about motivation and experiences
  2. Observation of attendance rates and effort levels during training sessions
  3. Surveys measuring only pre-program motivation levels
  4. Heart rate measurements during exercise sessions
Show Answers Only

Show Worked Solution

Consider Option A: Pre-post interviews asking open-ended questions about motivation and experiences

  • Pre-post interviews with open-ended questions provide the most comprehensive understanding because they allow participants to express complex changes in motivation in their own words.
  • Interviews can capture unexpected factors, personal insights, and detailed explanations about how and why motivation changed throughout the program, providing rich qualitative data that other methods cannot capture.

Other Options:

  • B is incorrect: Only captures external behaviors (attendance, effort) which may be influenced by factors other than motivation.
  • C is incorrect: Doesn’t measure changes in motivation since it only collects data at one time point.
  • D is incorrect: Measures physiological response to exercise, not psychological factors like motivation.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 434 MC

A student wants to investigate the relationship between aerobic training and perceived energy levels throughout the day in Year 11 students. Which data collection method would be most appropriate for this investigation?

  1. Observation of students during their regular classes
  2. Blood tests measuring ATP levels before and after training
  3. Survey with Likert scale questions about energy levels at different times of day
  4. Interview with teachers about students' classroom participation
Show Answers Only

Show Worked Solution

Consider Option C:  Survey with Likert scale questions about energy levels at different times of day

  • Survey with Likert scale questions is most appropriate because perceived energy levels are subjective experiences that are best measured through self-reporting.
  • A structured survey using a Likert scale (e.g., rating energy from 1-5) allows for quantifiable data collection about participants’ internal experiences throughout the day, which cannot be directly observed or measured through physiological tests.

Other Options:

  • A is incorrect: Inappropriate because energy levels are subjective internal states that cannot be reliably observed externally.
  • B is incorrect: Measures a physiological marker (ATP) rather than perceived energy levels, which is not what the research question is investigating.
  • D is incorrect: Relies on secondhand perceptions rather than direct reports from the participants experiencing the energy levels.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 433

After conducting an investigation into how a 12-week aerobic training program affected blood pressure responses to submaximal exercise, a student found that while resting blood pressure decreased for most participants, the blood pressure response during exercise showed minimal change.

Propose TWO further research questions that could be explored based on these findings.   (5 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer – or similar questions and reasons with required detail

  • “Is there a relationship between age and the blood pressure response to aerobic training at rest versus during exercise?” would investigate whether demographic factors influence how different aspects of blood pressure regulation adapt to training.
    • This question is valuable because it could help explain why resting blood pressure improved while exercise blood pressure didn’t, by examining whether age-related factors influence different physiological responses.
  • “How do the blood pressure responses at rest and during exercise compare between participants who reported high versus low enjoyment of the training program?” examines psychological influences on physiological responses.
    • This question explores the mind-body connection in exercise responses, potentially revealing whether engagement and enjoyment of the training program influences physiological adaptations.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer – or similar questions and reasons with required detail

  • “Is there a relationship between age and the blood pressure response to aerobic training at rest versus during exercise?” would investigate whether demographic factors influence how different aspects of blood pressure regulation adapt to training.
    • This question is valuable because it could help explain why resting blood pressure improved while exercise blood pressure didn’t, by examining whether age-related factors influence different physiological responses.
  • “How do the blood pressure responses at rest and during exercise compare between participants who reported high versus low enjoyment of the training program?” examines psychological influences on physiological responses.
    • This question explores the mind-body connection in exercise responses, potentially revealing whether engagement and enjoyment of the training program influences physiological adaptations.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 432

A student investigated how a 6-week aerobic training program affected recovery heart rate in Year 11 students. The results showed an average 9% improvement in 1-minute recovery heart rate following the program.

Identify ONE further research question that could be explored based on these findings and explain why this question would be valuable to investigate.   (3 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer – or similar question and reasons with required detail

  • “Does the improvement in recovery heart rate correlate with improvements in endurance performance?” would directly build on the positive physiological finding by connecting it to functional outcomes.
    • This question is valuable because it would establish whether the measured physiological adaptation (improved recovery heart rate) translates to meaningful performance benefits that participants can experience in sports or daily activities.
    • Understanding this relationship would help coaches and physical education teachers better communicate the practical benefits of training adaptations to students, potentially improving motivation and program adherence.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer – or similar question and reasons with required detail

  • “Does the improvement in recovery heart rate correlate with improvements in endurance performance?” would directly build on the positive physiological finding by connecting it to functional outcomes.
    • This question is valuable because it would establish whether the measured physiological adaptation (improved recovery heart rate) translates to meaningful performance benefits that participants can experience in sports or daily activities.
    • Understanding this relationship would help coaches and physical education teachers better communicate the practical benefits of training adaptations to students, potentially improving motivation and program adherence.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 431

A student investigated the effects of a 10-week aerobic training program on resting metabolic rate (RMR) in adolescents. The results showed that while RMR increased significantly for the group overall, there was considerable variation in individual responses.

Propose THREE further research questions that could be explored based on these findings and explain how each question would help understand physiological responses to aerobic training.   (10 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer – At least 3 questions including similar detail

  • “Is there a relationship between changes in resting metabolic rate and changes in resting heart rate following aerobic training?” investigates connections between different physiological measurements.
    • This question would help understand whether multiple physiological systems respond similarly to aerobic training or if they change independently, improving our understanding of how the body responds as a whole.
  • “Do males and females show similar changes in resting metabolic rate following the same aerobic training program?” examines potential sex differences in physiological responses.
    • Understanding how biological factors influence physiological responses to the same training stimulus would help explain the variation observed and could inform how different groups might respond to aerobic exercise.
  • “How do changes in resting metabolic rate differ between participants who trained in the morning versus those who trained in the afternoon?” investigates the influence of timing on physiological responses.
    • This question explores whether the body’s natural circadian rhythms affect how it responds to exercise, potentially explaining some of the individual variation observed in the original study.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer – At least 3 questions including similar detail

  • “Is there a relationship between changes in resting metabolic rate and changes in resting heart rate following aerobic training?” investigates connections between different physiological measurements.
    • This question would help understand whether multiple physiological systems respond similarly to aerobic training or if they change independently, improving our understanding of how the body responds as a whole.
  • “Do males and females show similar changes in resting metabolic rate following the same aerobic training program?” examines potential sex differences in physiological responses.
    • Understanding how biological factors influence physiological responses to the same training stimulus would help explain the variation observed and could inform how different groups might respond to aerobic exercise.
  • “How do changes in resting metabolic rate differ between participants who trained in the morning versus those who trained in the afternoon?” investigates the influence of timing on physiological responses.
    • This question explores whether the body’s natural circadian rhythms affect how it responds to exercise, potentially explaining some of the individual variation observed in the original study.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 430

A student investigated the relationship between perceived exertion and heart rate during a progressive aerobic exercise test. Results showed a strong correlation for most participants, but some individuals consistently reported lower perceived exertion despite similar heart rates to other participants.

Propose TWO further research questions based on these findings and explain how each question could enhance understanding of physiological responses to aerobic exercise.   (5 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer – Any 2 of the following or similar

  • “How does previous exercise experience affect the relationship between perceived exertion and heart rate during aerobic exercise?” directly addresses why some participants might perceive exercise differently despite similar physiological responses.
    • This question would enhance understanding of physiological responses by exploring how familiarity with exercise sensations might influence how individuals interpret and report their body’s responses during aerobic activity.
  • “Would the same disconnect between perceived exertion and heart rate occur during different types of aerobic activities, such as cycling versus running?” examines whether the physiological response patterns are activity-specific.
    • This question would improve understanding of how different exercise modes might produce varying relationships between objective measures (heart rate) and subjective feelings (perceived exertion), helping to explain individual differences in physiological responses.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer – Any 2 of the following or similar

  • “How does previous exercise experience affect the relationship between perceived exertion and heart rate during aerobic exercise?” directly addresses why some participants might perceive exercise differently despite similar physiological responses.
    • This question would enhance understanding of physiological responses by exploring how familiarity with exercise sensations might influence how individuals interpret and report their body’s responses during aerobic activity.
  • “Would the same disconnect between perceived exertion and heart rate occur during different types of aerobic activities, such as cycling versus running?” examines whether the physiological response patterns are activity-specific.
    • This question would improve understanding of how different exercise modes might produce varying relationships between objective measures (heart rate) and subjective feelings (perceived exertion), helping to explain individual differences in physiological responses.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 429

A student conducted research on the effects of a 12-week aerobic training program on stroke volume and cardiac output in adolescents. The results showed significant improvements in both measures at rest and during submaximal exercise, but the degree of improvement was strongly influenced by participants' initial fitness levels.

Evaluate TWO potential further research questions that could be explored based on these findings, justifying the scientific merit and practical application of each.   (8 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer – Any 2 of the following or similar

  • “How long do the improvements in stroke volume and cardiac output last after the cessation of the aerobic training program?” would investigate the duration of physiological adaptations when training stops.
    • This question has scientific merit as it explores whether these cardiovascular adaptations are temporary or more permanent, helping us understand how the body maintains training effects.
    • Practically, this could help determine how frequently training needs to occur to maintain cardiovascular benefits, which is useful for designing physical education programs that balance different activities throughout the school year.
  • “Do different types of aerobic training (swimming, running, cycling) produce similar improvements in stroke volume and cardiac output for adolescents with similar fitness levels?” examines the effect of training mode on physiological responses.
    • The scientific merit lies in understanding whether the cardiovascular system adapts similarly regardless of training type or if certain forms of exercise produce greater adaptations.
    • Practically, this could help identify the most effective types of aerobic activities to include in school-based fitness programs, especially for adolescents who might have preferences for certain activities.
  • “Is there a relationship between the improvements in stroke volume and cardiac output and changes in resting heart rate following the training program?” investigates connections between different physiological adaptations.
    • This question has scientific merit as it examines whether cardiovascular adaptations occur proportionally or independently, deepening our understanding of how the body responds to aerobic training.
    • The practical application includes potentially using simpler measurements (like resting heart rate) to track training adaptations when more complex measurements of stroke volume and cardiac output aren’t feasible in school settings.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer – Any 2 of the following or similar

  • “How long do the improvements in stroke volume and cardiac output last after the cessation of the aerobic training program?” would investigate the duration of physiological adaptations when training stops.
    • This question has scientific merit as it explores whether these cardiovascular adaptations are temporary or more permanent, helping us understand how the body maintains training effects.
    • Practically, this could help determine how frequently training needs to occur to maintain cardiovascular benefits, which is useful for designing physical education programs that balance different activities throughout the school year.
  • “Do different types of aerobic training (swimming, running, cycling) produce similar improvements in stroke volume and cardiac output for adolescents with similar fitness levels?” examines the effect of training mode on physiological responses.
    • The scientific merit lies in understanding whether the cardiovascular system adapts similarly regardless of training type or if certain forms of exercise produce greater adaptations.
    • Practically, this could help identify the most effective types of aerobic activities to include in school-based fitness programs, especially for adolescents who might have preferences for certain activities.
  • “Is there a relationship between the improvements in stroke volume and cardiac output and changes in resting heart rate following the training program?” investigates connections between different physiological adaptations.
    • This question has scientific merit as it examines whether cardiovascular adaptations occur proportionally or independently, deepening our understanding of how the body responds to aerobic training.
    • The practical application includes potentially using simpler measurements (like resting heart rate) to track training adaptations when more complex measurements of stroke volume and cardiac output aren’t feasible in school settings.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 428

A student investigated changes in lactate threshold following an 8-week high-intensity interval training program in recreational runners. The results showed an average 9% improvement in the speed at lactate threshold, but no significant change in maximum heart rate.

Identify TWO further research questions that could be explored based on these findings.   (4 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer – Any 2 of the following or similar

  • “Would a longer duration training program (e.g., 12 or 16 weeks) continue to improve lactate threshold at the same rate?” directly builds on the findings by exploring the duration aspect of the training program.
  • “How do these improvements in lactate threshold relate to changes in submaximal exercise performance?” connects the physiological measurement to practical outcomes that are observable in Year 11 investigations.
  • “Would different types of high-intensity interval training (varying work-to-rest ratios) produce different improvements in lactate threshold?” examines how modifying the exercise protocol might influence the physiological responses observed.
  • “Is there a correlation between initial fitness levels and the magnitude of improvement in lactate threshold following the training program?” explores individual differences in physiological responses to the same training stimulus.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer – Any 2 of the following or similar

  • “Would a longer duration training program (e.g., 12 or 16 weeks) continue to improve lactate threshold at the same rate?” directly builds on the findings by exploring the duration aspect of the training program.
  • “How do these improvements in lactate threshold relate to changes in submaximal exercise performance?” connects the physiological measurement to practical outcomes that are observable in Year 11 investigations.
  • “Would different types of high-intensity interval training (varying work-to-rest ratios) produce different improvements in lactate threshold?” examines how modifying the exercise protocol might influence the physiological responses observed.
  • “Is there a correlation between initial fitness levels and the magnitude of improvement in lactate threshold following the training program?” explores individual differences in physiological responses to the same training stimulus.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 427

A student conducted research investigating the relationship between heart rate recovery and oxygen saturation levels following a 12-minute Cooper test. The results showed a moderate correlation between faster heart rate recovery and higher oxygen saturation during exercise, but significant individual variation remained unexplained.

Propose THREE further research questions that would logically build on these findings. Explain the purpose and potential value of each question.   (6 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer – Other answers are possible.

  • “How does respiratory efficiency affect the relationship between heart rate recovery and oxygen saturation during aerobic exercise?” would explore physiological mechanisms that might explain the correlation found in the original study.
  • This question has value because understanding the underlying mechanisms would allow for more targeted training interventions that specifically enhance the physiological systems most responsible for the observed relationship.
  • “Do individuals with different aerobic training backgrounds (e.g., endurance athletes versus team sport athletes) show different relationships between heart rate recovery and oxygen saturation?” would investigate how training specificity affects these physiological parameters.
  • This question would help coaches and athletes develop more sport-specific training programs that optimise both cardiovascular recovery and oxygen utilisation for their particular needs.
  • “How consistent is the relationship between heart rate recovery and oxygen saturation across different exercise intensities and durations?” would examine whether the moderate correlation holds under various exercise conditions.
  • Understanding intensity-specific relationships would enable more precise training prescriptions for individuals with different fitness goals, from health improvement to competitive performance.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer – Other answers are possible.

  • “How does respiratory efficiency affect the relationship between heart rate recovery and oxygen saturation during aerobic exercise?” would explore physiological mechanisms that might explain the correlation found in the original study.
  • This question has value because understanding the underlying mechanisms would allow for more targeted training interventions that specifically enhance the physiological systems most responsible for the observed relationship.
  • “Do individuals with different aerobic training backgrounds (e.g., endurance athletes versus team sport athletes) show different relationships between heart rate recovery and oxygen saturation?” would investigate how training specificity affects these physiological parameters.
  • This question would help coaches and athletes develop more sport-specific training programs that optimise both cardiovascular recovery and oxygen utilisation for their particular needs.
  • “How consistent is the relationship between heart rate recovery and oxygen saturation across different exercise intensities and durations?” would examine whether the moderate correlation holds under various exercise conditions.
  • Understanding intensity-specific relationships would enable more precise training prescriptions for individuals with different fitness goals, from health improvement to competitive performance.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 426

After investigating the effects of a 10-week aerobic training program on respiratory rate during submaximal exercise, a student found that while recovery time improved for all participants, the magnitude of improvement varied considerably across the study group of 15 Year 11 students.

Propose TWO appropriate further research questions that could be explored based on these findings.   (4 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer – Any TWO of the following or similar with adequate detail.

  • “How does the type of aerobic training (continuous vs. interval) affect respiratory recovery time improvements?” would investigate whether different training methods produce varying magnitudes of adaptation.
  • “Is there a relationship between respiratory recovery improvements and changes in other physiological measures such as heart rate recovery or VO₂ max?” would examine connections between different physiological adaptations to determine if they occur proportionally.
  • “How does initial fitness level affect the magnitude of respiratory adaptations to aerobic training?” would help identify whether pre-training fitness explains the variation in improvement between participants.
  • “Do respiratory adaptations continue at the same rate beyond 10 weeks of training, or does improvement plateau?” would determine the optimal duration for maximum benefits from the training program.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • “How does the type of aerobic training (continuous vs. interval) affect respiratory recovery time improvements?” would investigate whether different training methods produce varying magnitudes of adaptation.
  • “Is there a relationship between respiratory recovery improvements and changes in other physiological measures such as heart rate recovery or VO₂ max?” would examine connections between different physiological adaptations to determine if they occur proportionally.
  • “How does initial fitness level affect the magnitude of respiratory adaptations to aerobic training?” would help identify whether pre-training fitness explains the variation in improvement between participants.
  • “Do respiratory adaptations continue at the same rate beyond 10 weeks of training, or does improvement plateau?” would determine the optimal duration for maximum benefits from the training program.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 425

A student investigated how a 6-week aerobic training program affected resting heart rate in Year 11 students. Results showed an average decrease of 7 beats per minute, but some participants showed no change at all.

Identify ONE further research question that could be explored based on these findings and explain why this question would be valuable to investigate.   (3 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer – Any ONE of the following or similar with same level of detail

Example 1

  • A valuable follow-up question would be “What factors influenced whether a participant experienced a reduction in resting heart rate?” as this directly addresses the variation in results identified in the original study.
  • This question is valuable because it would help identify which participant characteristics (such as initial fitness level, adherence to the program, or genetic factors) determine training responsiveness.
  • Understanding these factors would allow future training programs to be modified or personalised to increase effectiveness for all participants, improving health outcomes for those who didn’t respond to the standard protocol.

Example 2

  • “Does the frequency of aerobic training sessions per week affect the magnitude of resting heart rate reduction?” would be a valuable follow-up question as it investigates whether training volume was a factor in the varied responses.
  • This question is valuable because it directly addresses program design, potentially identifying whether non-responders simply need more frequent training sessions to achieve similar benefits to those who showed improvements.
  • Results could help establish minimum effective training frequencies for resting heart rate adaptations in adolescents, improving the efficiency of school-based physical education programs.

Example 3

  • “Is there a correlation between baseline fitness levels and the magnitude of resting heart rate reduction following a 6-week aerobic training program?” would explore whether initial conditioning predicts responsiveness.
  • This question is valuable because it would help identify whether the program was more effective for certain fitness profiles, allowing for better participant screening or customised program durations based on starting fitness.
  • Understanding this relationship would enable more personalised and efficient interventions by helping educators predict which students might need modified programs to achieve cardiovascular adaptations.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer – Any ONE of the following or similar with same level of detail

Example 1

  • A valuable follow-up question would be “What factors influenced whether a participant experienced a reduction in resting heart rate?” as this directly addresses the variation in results identified in the original study.
  • This question is valuable because it would help identify which participant characteristics (such as initial fitness level, adherence to the program, or genetic factors) determine training responsiveness.
  • Understanding these factors would allow future training programs to be modified or personalised to increase effectiveness for all participants, improving health outcomes for those who didn’t respond to the standard protocol.

Example 2

  • “Does the frequency of aerobic training sessions per week affect the magnitude of resting heart rate reduction?” would be a valuable follow-up question as it investigates whether training volume was a factor in the varied responses.
  • This question is valuable because it directly addresses program design, potentially identifying whether non-responders simply need more frequent training sessions to achieve similar benefits to those who showed improvements.
  • Results could help establish minimum effective training frequencies for resting heart rate adaptations in adolescents, improving the efficiency of school-based physical education programs.

Example 3

  • “Is there a correlation between baseline fitness levels and the magnitude of resting heart rate reduction following a 6-week aerobic training program?” would explore whether initial conditioning predicts responsiveness.
  • This question is valuable because it would help identify whether the program was more effective for certain fitness profiles, allowing for better participant screening or customised program durations based on starting fitness.
  • Understanding this relationship would enable more personalised and efficient interventions by helping educators predict which students might need modified programs to achieve cardiovascular adaptations.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 424 MC

A research study investigating the relationship between aerobic training and stress hormone levels found that participants with the greatest improvements in aerobic capacity also showed the largest reductions in cortisol levels at rest. However, the study didn't measure cortisol levels during exercise.

Which of the following represents the most sophisticated further research question based on these findings?

  1. Does aerobic training reduce stress hormone levels during everyday activities?
  2. Are cortisol reductions maintained if aerobic training is discontinued?
  3. Would resistance training show similar effects on cortisol levels as aerobic training?
  4. How do changes in cortisol during exercise relate to improvements in resting cortisol levels following aerobic training?
Show Answers Only

Show Worked Solution

Consider Option D:  How do changes in cortisol during exercise relate to improvements in resting cortisol levels following aerobic training?

  • This option directly represents the most sophisticated further research question as it builds directly on the gap identified in the original study (not measuring cortisol during exercise) while maintaining focus on the relationship between aerobic capacity improvements and cortisol regulation.
  • This question seeks to understand the physiological mechanisms that link training adaptations to hormone regulation.

Other Options:

  • A is incorrect: Broadens the scope to everyday activities rather than focusing on understanding the exercise-specific response.
  • B is incorrect: Looks at maintenance effects rather than deepening understanding of the mechanisms.
  • C is incorrect: Shifts focus to a different type of training rather than building on the findings about aerobic training.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 423 MC

A student conducted research on the effects of aerobic training on blood pressure in Year 11 students. The results showed a significant decrease in resting blood pressure after 8 weeks of training for male participants, but minimal changes for female participants.

What would be the most appropriate follow-up research question?

  1. Do females require different types of aerobic training to achieve blood pressure reductions?
  2. Is aerobic training an effective intervention for reducing blood pressure?
  3. How long do blood pressure reductions last after the training program ends?
  4. What is the ideal exercise intensity for blood pressure reduction?
Show Answers Only

Show Worked Solution

Consider Option A: Do females require different types of aerobic training to achieve blood pressure reductions?

  • This option directly addresses the gender difference observed in the results, seeking to understand why females responded differently to the same training protocol.
  • This builds directly on the findings and could help develop more effective, targeted interventions.

Other Options:

  • B is incorrect: Asks a question that has already been partly answered by the original study (showing effectiveness for males).
  • C is incorrect: Focuses on the duration of effects rather than addressing the gender difference found in the results.
  • D is incorrect: Asks about optimisation without first addressing why the current protocol was ineffective for females.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 422 MC

A student conducted research on changes in lung capacity following an 8-week aerobic swimming program. The results showed significant improvements in vital capacity but no change in forced expiratory volume.

Which research question would most logically build upon these findings?

  1. How does swimming compare to cycling for developing respiratory fitness?
  2. Does vital capacity continue to improve beyond 8 weeks of swim training?
  3. Why does vital capacity improve while forced expiratory volume remains unchanged during swim training?
  4. What is the best way to measure lung capacity changes in adolescent swimmers?
Show Answers Only

Show Worked Solution

Consider Option C: Why does vital capacity improve while forced expiratory volume remains unchanged during swim training?

  • This option directly addresses the unexpected discrepancy found in the results – that vital capacity improved but forced expiratory volume did not.
  • This question seeks to understand the physiological mechanisms behind this finding, which represents the most logical next step in building knowledge from the original investigation.

Other Options:

  • A is incorrect: Compares different types of training rather than building on the specific findings of this study.
  • B is incorrect: Only focuses on the duration of effects for one parameter without addressing the discrepancy.
  • D is incorrect: Focuses on measurement methodology rather than understanding the physiological response discovered.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 421 MC

After completing a 6-week aerobic training program investigating heart rate recovery in teenagers, a student found significant improvements in participants' recovery times but noticed that results varied considerably between individuals.

Which of the following represents the most appropriate further research question based on these findings?

  1. Would a 12-week program show greater improvements in heart rate recovery?
  2. How do different exercise intensities affect heart rate recovery improvements?
  3. Why is heart rate recovery a reliable indicator of cardiovascular fitness?
  4. Does heart rate recovery improve at the same rate for all types of aerobic exercise?
Show Answers Only

Show Worked Solution

Consider Option B: How do different exercise intensities affect heart rate recovery improvements?

  • This option directly addresses the variability in the results.
  • By investigating how different exercise intensities affect heart rate recovery improvements, the student could explore why participants responded differently to the same training program, potentially identifying optimal training zones for different individuals.

Other Options:

  • A is incorrect: Simply extends the duration without addressing the variability in results.
  • C is incorrect: Focuses on validation of the measurement method rather than building on the findings.
  • D is incorrect: Too broad and doesn’t specifically address the individual differences noted in the results.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 420

During an investigation into aerobic training responses, a researcher collected data on participants' maximum heart rates using a variety of consumer fitness watches.

Assess the potential impact of this approach on the validity, reliability, and credibility of the investigation. Provide recommendations for improvement.   (5 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer 

  • Using various consumer fitness watches introduces significant reliability issues through inconsistent measurement algorithms and sensor technologies between devices, creating systematic error in comparing participants’ data.
  • The validity of consumer watches for maximum heart rate measurement is questionable as they typically prioritise comfort and battery life over measurement precision, potentially underestimating true maximum heart rates during intense exercise.
  • The credibility of the investigation is compromised when using non-research-grade equipment without established validity against criterion measures like ECG, particularly for maximum heart rates where accuracy is most critical.
  • To improve reliability, the researcher should standardise by using identical devices for all participants and conduct preliminary testing to establish the consistency of measurements across multiple trials.
  • Validity would be enhanced by validating the selected device against a criterion measure (such as ECG or chest strap monitor) during a pilot study, or by selecting a research-validated consumer device with documented accuracy during high-intensity exercise.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • Using various consumer fitness watches introduces significant reliability issues through inconsistent measurement algorithms and sensor technologies between devices, creating systematic error in comparing participants’ data.
  • The validity of consumer watches for maximum heart rate measurement is questionable as they typically prioritise comfort and battery life over measurement precision, potentially underestimating true maximum heart rates during intense exercise.
  • The credibility of the investigation is compromised when using non-research-grade equipment without established validity against criterion measures like ECG, particularly for maximum heart rates where accuracy is most critical.
  • To improve reliability, the researcher should standardise by using identical devices for all participants and conduct preliminary testing to establish the consistency of measurements across multiple trials.
  • Validity would be enhanced by validating the selected device against a criterion measure (such as ECG or chest strap monitor) during a pilot study, or by selecting a research-validated consumer device with documented accuracy during high-intensity exercise.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 419

A school-based research project is investigating the physiological adaptations to a 10-week aerobic training program using both direct (laboratory) and indirect (field-based) measurements.

Critically analyse how the choice of data collection methods affects the validity, reliability, and credibility of findings in physiological investigations of aerobic training.   (8 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer 

  • Laboratory tests like VO₂ max testing give more accurate results because they directly measure oxygen use, but field tests like the Beep Test better show how people perform in real sports situations.
  • Schools often can’t afford expensive lab equipment, so they use field tests which are easier to run but less precise, making researchers choose between perfect measurements and what’s actually possible.
  • Lab equipment is complicated to use correctly and requires training, so when inexperienced students or teachers handle it, the results might not be as consistent as they should be.
  • Field tests don’t always give the same results when repeated because they’re done in less controlled environments, but they might better motivate participants to try their hardest because they feel more like real competition.
  • Testing too often can give more detailed results about how fitness improves, but participants might get better at the tests just from practise, which can make it look like the training is more effective than it really is.
  • Using multiple types of measurements together (like heart rate, how hard the exercise feels, and performance scores) can give a better overall picture despite limitations of each individual measure.
  • Researchers might unconsciously influence results if they expect certain outcomes, so it’s important to have neutral people conduct the tests when possible.
  • School research needs to be honest about what the methods can and cannot show, rather than claiming the results are more accurate than they really are.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • Laboratory tests like VO₂ max testing give more accurate results because they directly measure oxygen use, but field tests like the Beep Test better show how people perform in real sports situations.
  • Schools often can’t afford expensive lab equipment, so they use field tests which are easier to run but less precise, making researchers choose between perfect measurements and what’s actually possible.
  • Lab equipment is complicated to use correctly and requires training, so when inexperienced students or teachers handle it, the results might not be as consistent as they should be.
  • Field tests don’t always give the same results when repeated because they’re done in less controlled environments, but they might better motivate participants to try their hardest because they feel more like real competition.
  • Testing too often can give more detailed results about how fitness improves, but participants might get better at the tests just from practise, which can make it look like the training is more effective than it really is.
  • Using multiple types of measurements together (like heart rate, how hard the exercise feels, and performance scores) can give a better overall picture despite limitations of each individual measure.
  • Researchers might unconsciously influence results if they expect certain outcomes, so it’s important to have neutral people conduct the tests when possible.
  • School research needs to be honest about what the methods can and cannot show, rather than claiming the results are more accurate than they really are.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 418

In an aerobic training investigation, a student collected heart rate data immediately after a 12-minute Cooper run test. The student conducted the test on a school oval without marking the exact distance covered.

Identify TWO limitations of this data collection approach and explain how each affects the reliability of the results.   (3 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer – Any 2 of the following

  • Not marking the exact distance covered creates inconsistency in performance measurement, reducing reliability as participants may run different distances in pre- and post-tests despite similar perceived effort levels.
  • Collecting heart rate only immediately after exercise, rather than at multiple time points during recovery, limits reliability as single measurements are more susceptible to momentary fluctuations and timing errors.
  • Failure to standardise pre-test conditions such as nutrition, hydration, sleep quality, or prior physical activity can lead to physiological variations unrelated to the training intervention, reducing reliability between testing sessions.
  • The absence of consistent environmental controls (temperature, humidity, wind conditions, surface conditions) on the school oval can significantly impact running performance and heart rate responses, creating test-retest variability.
  • Lack of standardised heart rate measurement technique and timing (exact seconds after exercise cessation) leads to inconsistent recovery phase measurements, as heart rate decreases rapidly after exercise stops.
  • Without precise timing protocols, the duration of the test itself might vary slightly between testing sessions, affecting the physiological demands and subsequent heart rate responses.
  • The absence of a standardised warm-up protocol before the test can result in different starting physiological states, influencing both performance and heart rate responses.
  • Failure to account for or control psychological factors like motivation, competition between participants, or external distractions on the school oval could affect effort levels and heart rate responses.
  • Without proper equipment calibration (if using heart rate monitors) or consistent manual pulse-taking technique (if done manually), the heart rate measurements themselves may lack precision and consistency.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer – Any 2 of the following

  • Not marking the exact distance covered creates inconsistency in performance measurement, reducing reliability as participants may run different distances in pre- and post-tests despite similar perceived effort levels.
  • Collecting heart rate only immediately after exercise, rather than at multiple time points during recovery, limits reliability as single measurements are more susceptible to momentary fluctuations and timing errors.
  • Failure to standardise pre-test conditions such as nutrition, hydration, sleep quality, or prior physical activity can lead to physiological variations unrelated to the training intervention, reducing reliability between testing sessions.
  • The absence of consistent environmental controls (temperature, humidity, wind conditions, surface conditions) on the school oval can significantly impact running performance and heart rate responses, creating test-retest variability.
  • Lack of standardised heart rate measurement technique and timing (exact seconds after exercise cessation) leads to inconsistent recovery phase measurements, as heart rate decreases rapidly after exercise stops.
  • Without precise timing protocols, the duration of the test itself might vary slightly between testing sessions, affecting the physiological demands and subsequent heart rate responses.
  • The absence of a standardised warm-up protocol before the test can result in different starting physiological states, influencing both performance and heart rate responses.
  • Failure to account for or control psychological factors like motivation, competition between participants, or external distractions on the school oval could affect effort levels and heart rate responses.
  • Without proper equipment calibration (if using heart rate monitors) or consistent manual pulse-taking technique (if done manually), the heart rate measurements themselves may lack precision and consistency.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 417

A student is designing an investigation to measure changes in stroke volume following an 8-week high-intensity interval training program.

Evaluate the challenges in ensuring valid, reliable, and credible data collection when measuring complex physiological responses to aerobic training.   (6 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer

  • Measuring stroke volume accurately is difficult in a school setting because it requires special equipment that most schools don’t have, so students often use less accurate methods that might not show the true physiological changes.
  • Many factors like whether participants had food or water before testing, how much they exercised recently, or even if they’re nervous can affect heart measurements, making it hard to get reliable results unless these factors are strictly controlled.
  • Students might not try their hardest during testing if they know they’re being observed, which affects how valid the results are because the measurements won’t show their true maximum capacity.
  • Heart measurements like stroke volume naturally change from day to day in the same person, which makes it hard to tell if changes are from the training program or just normal variation.
  • Schools usually can’t access the best measurement tools (like heart imaging machines), so they have to use simpler methods that might not be as trusted by scientists.
  • To deal with these challenges, students should use multiple ways to measure the same thing, keep testing conditions as similar as possible each time, and be honest about the limitations of their methods.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • Measuring stroke volume accurately is difficult in a school setting because it requires special equipment that most schools don’t have, so students often use less accurate methods that might not show the true physiological changes.
  • Many factors like whether participants had food or water before testing, how much they exercised recently, or even if they’re nervous can affect heart measurements, making it hard to get reliable results unless these factors are strictly controlled.
  • Students might not try their hardest during testing if they know they’re being observed, which affects how valid the results are because the measurements won’t show their true maximum capacity.
  • Heart measurements like stroke volume naturally change from day to day in the same person, which makes it hard to tell if changes are from the training program or just normal variation.
  • Schools usually can’t access the best measurement tools (like heart imaging machines), so they have to use simpler methods that might not be as trusted by scientists.
  • To deal with these challenges, students should use multiple ways to measure the same thing, keep testing conditions as similar as possible each time, and be honest about the limitations of their methods.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 416

A research team is investigating the relationship between aerobic training and blood pressure responses.

Discuss the importance of using valid and reliable data collection methods when investigating physiological responses to aerobic training.   (5 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer

  • Valid data collection methods ensure that the physiological variables being measured (such as blood pressure) genuinely reflect the aerobic training adaptations being studied, rather than confounding factors like measurement timing or technique.
  • Reliable methods allow researchers to attribute observed changes to the training intervention rather than to inconsistencies in measurement technique, equipment performance, or environmental conditions.
  • The combination of validity and reliability enables accurate quantification of training effects, which is crucial for determining optimal training prescriptions for specific health outcomes like blood pressure reduction.
  • Invalid or unreliable methods may lead to incorrect conclusions about the effectiveness of aerobic training interventions, potentially resulting in inappropriate exercise recommendations that could impact health outcomes.
  • Scientifically sound data collection methods enhance the credibility of findings among the scientific community, facilitating knowledge translation from research to practical applications in fitness and health settings.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • Valid data collection methods ensure that the physiological variables being measured (such as blood pressure) genuinely reflect the aerobic training adaptations being studied, rather than confounding factors like measurement timing or technique.
  • Reliable methods allow researchers to attribute observed changes to the training intervention rather than to inconsistencies in measurement technique, equipment performance, or environmental conditions.
  • The combination of validity and reliability enables accurate quantification of training effects, which is crucial for determining optimal training prescriptions for specific health outcomes like blood pressure reduction.
  • Invalid or unreliable methods may lead to incorrect conclusions about the effectiveness of aerobic training interventions, potentially resulting in inappropriate exercise recommendations that could impact health outcomes.
  • Scientifically sound data collection methods enhance the credibility of findings among the scientific community, facilitating knowledge translation from research to practical applications in fitness and health settings.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 415

In a school-based investigation on the effects of aerobic training on cardiovascular efficiency, researchers must carefully consider ethical implications alongside validity, reliability, and credibility.

Analyse how ethical considerations in data collection might impact the validity, reliability, and credibility of the investigation's findings.   (6 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer

  • Informed consent requirements may limit data collection methods to non-invasive procedures, potentially reducing validity if the most valid measures (such as blood lactate sampling) are excluded in favor of less invasive but less direct measurements.
  • Participant comfort and safety concerns may necessitate modifications to testing protocols, such as submaximal rather than maximal testing, which creates a reliability trade-off between participant welfare and obtaining the most consistent physiological responses.
  • The need to accommodate varying fitness levels ethically requires individualised protocols or early termination criteria, introducing methodological variability that may compromise the standardisation required for high reliability.
  • Privacy and confidentiality obligations might restrict the collection of potentially relevant health information or demographic data, limiting the ability to identify confounding variables that could impact validity.
  • Ethical requirements for voluntary participation acknowledge participants’ right to withdraw, potentially creating self-selection bias or incomplete data sets that affect the credibility of findings.
  • Despite these challenges, adhering to ethical standards ultimately enhances credibility as it demonstrates scientific integrity and responsible research practices, even if methodological compromises are made.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • Informed consent requirements may limit data collection methods to non-invasive procedures, potentially reducing validity if the most valid measures (such as blood lactate sampling) are excluded in favor of less invasive but less direct measurements.
  • Participant comfort and safety concerns may necessitate modifications to testing protocols, such as submaximal rather than maximal testing, which creates a reliability trade-off between participant welfare and obtaining the most consistent physiological responses.
  • The need to accommodate varying fitness levels ethically requires individualised protocols or early termination criteria, introducing methodological variability that may compromise the standardisation required for high reliability.
  • Privacy and confidentiality obligations might restrict the collection of potentially relevant health information or demographic data, limiting the ability to identify confounding variables that could impact validity.
  • Ethical requirements for voluntary participation acknowledge participants’ right to withdraw, potentially creating self-selection bias or incomplete data sets that affect the credibility of findings.
  • Despite these challenges, adhering to ethical standards ultimately enhances credibility as it demonstrates scientific integrity and responsible research practices, even if methodological compromises are made.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 414

A student is investigating changes in respiratory rate during submaximal exercise following an 8-week aerobic training program.

Compare the validity and reliability in the context of this physiological investigation.   (4 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer

  • Validity in this investigation refers to whether respiratory rate measurements accurately reflect the physiological adaptations to aerobic training.
  • Reliability refers to the consistency of measurements across multiple testing sessions.
  • High validity would be achieved by ensuring the exercise protocol adequately challenges the respiratory system at appropriate intensities to demonstrate training effects.
  • High reliability would be achieved through consistent counting methods and standardised breathing pattern instructions.
  • Validity might be compromised if respiratory rate is measured during inappropriate exercise intensities that don’t reflect aerobic adaptations.
  • Reliability might be compromised if different counting methods are used pre- and post-training.
  • Both validity and reliability are essential yet distinct qualities;
    • Valid but unreliable measurements would accurately reflect respiratory adaptations but produce inconsistent results
    • While reliable but invalid measurements would yield consistent results that don’t actually represent the training adaptations being studied.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • Validity in this investigation refers to whether respiratory rate measurements accurately reflect the physiological adaptations to aerobic training.
  • Reliability refers to the consistency of measurements across multiple testing sessions.
  • High validity would be achieved by ensuring the exercise protocol adequately challenges the respiratory system at appropriate intensities to demonstrate training effects.
  • High reliability would be achieved through consistent counting methods and standardised breathing pattern instructions.
  • Validity might be compromised if respiratory rate is measured during inappropriate exercise intensities that don’t reflect aerobic adaptations.
  • Reliability might be compromised if different counting methods are used pre- and post-training.
  • Both validity and reliability are essential yet distinct qualities;
    • Valid but unreliable measurements would accurately reflect respiratory adaptations but produce inconsistent results
    • While reliable but invalid measurements would yield consistent results that don’t actually represent the training adaptations being studied.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 413

When discussing the credibility of data collection in physiological investigations, researchers must consider multiple factors.

Explain THREE factors that influence the credibility of data in an investigation measuring VO₂ max changes following an aerobic training program.   (5 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer – Any 3 of the following

  • The qualifications and expertise of the researcher administering the tests directly impacts credibility, as proper protocol execution requires technical knowledge and experience with specialised equipment to ensure accurate VO₂ max measurements.
  • The reputation and calibration status of testing equipment significantly affects credibility, as validated, regularly calibrated equipment provides more trusted results than uncalibrated or consumer-grade alternatives.
  • Sample size and selection methods influence the credibility of findings, as larger, representative samples with appropriate inclusion/exclusion criteria yield more believable results than convenient or biassed selections.
  • Transparency in reporting of methods, including detailed documentation of testing protocols, environmental conditions, and any deviations from planned procedures, enhances the credibility of the collected data by allowing for external scrutiny.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer – Any 3 of the following

  • The qualifications and expertise of the researcher administering the tests directly impacts credibility, as proper protocol execution requires technical knowledge and experience with specialised equipment to ensure accurate VO₂ max measurements.
  • The reputation and calibration status of testing equipment significantly affects credibility, as validated, regularly calibrated equipment provides more trusted results than uncalibrated or consumer-grade alternatives.
  • Sample size and selection methods influence the credibility of findings, as larger, representative samples with appropriate inclusion/exclusion criteria yield more believable results than convenient or biassed selections.
  • Transparency in reporting of methods, including detailed documentation of testing protocols, environmental conditions, and any deviations from planned procedures, enhances the credibility of the collected data by allowing for external scrutiny.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 412

A Year 11 student is investigating the effects of a 6-week aerobic training program on lactic acid threshold in recreational runners.

Explain how the student could enhance the reliability of their data collection.   (4 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer 

  • Standardise testing protocols by conducting all threshold tests at the same time of day to minimise variation from circadian rhythms that affect physiological responses.
  • Ensure consistent testing conditions including temperature, humidity and surface type for all pre and post-training assessments.
  • Use the same calibrated equipment throughout the entire investigation to eliminate measurement discrepancies from different devices.
  • Provide clear, detailed instructions to participants regarding pre-test preparations (such as sleep, nutrition, and prior exercise) to control extraneous variables that could impact results.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer 

  • Standardise testing protocols by conducting all threshold tests at the same time of day to minimise variation from circadian rhythms that affect physiological responses.
  • Ensure consistent testing conditions including temperature, humidity and surface type for all pre and post-training assessments.
  • Use the same calibrated equipment throughout the entire investigation to eliminate measurement discrepancies from different devices.
  • Provide clear, detailed instructions to participants regarding pre-test preparations (such as sleep, nutrition, and prior exercise) to control extraneous variables that could impact results.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 411

When investigating physiological responses to aerobic training, a researcher must consider the validity of their data collection methods.

Outline TWO factors that could impact the validity of heart rate measurements during an aerobic training investigation.   (3 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer – Any 2 of the following

  • Environmental factors such as temperature and humidity can affect heart rate responses, potentially invalidating results if not controlled for, as they may influence the physiological variable being measured rather than the training itself.
  • Psychological factors including anxiety or nervousness around testing equipment can artificially elevate heart rate measurements, reducing validity as the numbers reflect stress responses rather than true training adaptations.
  • Measurement technique or equipment issues, such as incorrect placement of heart rate monitors, use of different monitoring devices between tests, or equipment malfunction/calibration errors, can result in inaccurate readings that don’t reflect true physiological responses.
  • Prior activity and lifestyle factors including recent food intake, caffeine consumption, medication use, or physical activity before testing can artificially alter heart rate responses, reducing the validity of measurements as indicators of training adaptations.
  • Subject-specific physiological variables like hydration status, illness, fatigue levels, or hormonal fluctuations (particularly in female participants) can significantly affect heart rate measurements, compromising validity if not controlled or accounted for.
  • Testing protocol inconsistencies including variations in warm-up procedures, exercise intensity, duration of measurement periods, or recovery intervals between testing components can invalidate comparisons between pre- and post-training measurements.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer – Any 2 of the following

  • Environmental factors such as temperature and humidity can affect heart rate responses, potentially invalidating results if not controlled for, as they may influence the physiological variable being measured rather than the training itself.
  • Psychological factors including anxiety or nervousness around testing equipment can artificially elevate heart rate measurements, reducing validity as the numbers reflect stress responses rather than true training adaptations.
  • Measurement technique or equipment issues, such as incorrect placement of heart rate monitors, use of different monitoring devices between tests, or equipment malfunction/calibration errors, can result in inaccurate readings that don’t reflect true physiological responses.
  • Prior activity and lifestyle factors including recent food intake, caffeine consumption, medication use, or physical activity before testing can artificially alter heart rate responses, reducing the validity of measurements as indicators of training adaptations.
  • Subject-specific physiological variables like hydration status, illness, fatigue levels, or hormonal fluctuations (particularly in female participants) can significantly affect heart rate measurements, compromising validity if not controlled or accounted for.
  • Testing protocol inconsistencies including variations in warm-up procedures, exercise intensity, duration of measurement periods, or recovery intervals between testing components can invalidate comparisons between pre- and post-training measurements.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 410 MC

A fitness instructor wants to investigate the effect of different aerobic training intensities on resting heart rate. Which data collection method would yield the most credible results?

  1. Having participants self-report their resting heart rates each morning.
  2. Using a standardised laboratory protocol with calibrated heart rate monitors.
  3. Conducting manual pulse readings by different staff members throughout the week.
  4. Measuring heart rates immediately after participants arrive at the fitness center.
Show Answers Only

Show Worked Solution

Consider Option B: 

  • Using a standardised laboratory protocol with calibrated equipment provides the most credible results because it controls for variables and ensures measurements are taken under consistent conditions with accurate, scientifically validated equipment.

Other Options:

  • A is incorrect: Lacks credibility due to potential inconsistencies in self-reporting methods and participant error.
  • C is incorrect: Introduces variability from different staff members’ measuring techniques, reducing reliability.
  • D is incorrect: Problematic because measurements taken immediately upon arrival can be influenced by recent activity (walking, driving, etc.), not truly reflecting resting heart rate.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 409 MC

A student conducted a study measuring changes in oxygen uptake during a 10-week aerobic training program, but the data showed unusual fluctuations. Upon review, it was discovered that the testing was performed in varying environmental conditions (different room temperatures, humidity levels, and times of day).

Which statement best describes the issue with this data collection approach?

  1. The data lacks reliability because measurements were taken under inconsistent conditions.
  2. The data lacks validity because oxygen uptake doesn't measure aerobic adaptations.
  3. The data lacks credibility because the testing equipment wasn't properly calibrated.
  4. The data lacks accuracy because the training program was too short to show results.
Show Answers Only

Show Worked Solution

Consider Option A: 

  • The data lacks reliability because measurements were taken under inconsistent conditions.
  • Reliability refers to the consistency of results, and when environmental conditions vary (temperature, humidity, time of day), they act as confounding variables that reduce the consistency of the measurements.

Other Options:

  • B is incorrect: Oxygen uptake is a valid measure of aerobic adaptation; the issue isn’t with what’s being measured.
  • C is incorrect: There’s no indication in the scenario that the equipment wasn’t calibrated; the issue is with the inconsistent testing conditions.
  • D is incorrect: A 10-week program is typically sufficient to observe aerobic adaptations; the issue is with the varying testing conditions, not the length of the program.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 408 MC

A researcher is investigating the impact of aerobic training on VO₂ max over an 8-week period. Which of the following data collection approaches would most significantly improve the validity of the research?

  1. Testing participants using the same equipment at the same time of day for each measurement.
  2. Using a control group of participants who do not participate in the aerobic training program.
  3. Recruiting a large sample of 1,000 participants from diverse fitness backgrounds.
  4. Publishing the research findings in a peer-reviewed journal.
Show Answers Only

Show Worked Solution

Consider Option B: 

  • Using a control group improves validity because it allows researchers to determine whether changes in VO₂ max are due to the aerobic training intervention rather than other factors (like maturation or external variables).
  • This helps establish causality and strengthens the internal validity of the investigation.

Other Options:

  • A is incorrect: Improves reliability (consistency of measurements) but doesn’t primarily address validity.
  • C is incorrect: May improve generalisability (external validity) but doesn’t specifically address whether the test accurately measures the impact of aerobic training.
  • D is incorrect: Relates to credibility through peer review but occurs after data collection and doesn’t impact the validity of the original data collection method.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 407 MC

A student conducted an investigation on heart rate recovery after aerobic exercise by measuring participants' heart rates at 1-minute intervals following a step test. The student found that measurements varied significantly when using different pulse-taking methods (wrist, neck, and chest monitor).

Which statement best explains the issue with the data collection method?

  1. The investigation lacks credibility because heart rate recovery isn't a valid measure of aerobic fitness.
  2. The investigation lacks validity because different pulse-taking methods were not calibrated against each other.
  3. The investigation lacks reliability because inconsistent measuring techniques were used across participants.
  4. The investigation lacks credibility because a step test isn't an appropriate activity for testing aerobic fitness.
Show Answers Only

Show Worked Solution

Consider Option C: 

  • The investigation lacks reliability because using different pulse-taking methods without standardisation creates inconsistency in the measurements.
  • Reliability refers to the consistency of results when repeated measurements are taken, and in this case, the varying methods reduce the reliability of the data.

Other Options:

  • A is incorrect: Heart rate recovery is a valid measure of aerobic fitness; the issue is not with the validity of what’s being measured.
  • B is incorrect: While calibration is important, the primary issue here is the inconsistent application of measuring techniques (a reliability issue), not validity.
  • D is incorrect: Step tests are widely accepted as appropriate for testing aerobic fitness; the credibility of the method itself is not in question.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 406

Explain the ethical considerations when using video recording to analyse breathing patterns during an aerobic training investigation.   (4 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer

  • Specific consent for video recording must be obtained separately from general participation consent, clearly explaining how the footage will be used, stored, and eventually destroyed.
  • Participant privacy must be protected by recording in an appropriate setting away from uninvolved observers and ensuring the camera angle focuses only on relevant areas (chest/torso) for breathing analysis.
  • Access to video recordings should be strictly limited to those directly involved in the analysis process to maintain confidentiality.
  • Participants should be given the option to review their own footage and request deletion if they feel uncomfortable with the recording, respecting their ongoing right to control their personal data.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • Specific consent for video recording must be obtained separately from general participation consent, clearly explaining how the footage will be used, stored, and eventually destroyed.
  • Participant privacy must be protected by recording in an appropriate setting away from uninvolved observers and ensuring the camera angle focuses only on relevant areas (chest/torso) for breathing analysis.
  • Access to video recordings should be strictly limited to those directly involved in the analysis process to maintain confidentiality.
  • Participants should be given the option to review their own footage and request deletion if they feel uncomfortable with the recording, respecting their ongoing right to control their personal data.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 405

Outline the ethical responsibilities researchers have when collecting data from participants during an aerobic training investigation.   (3 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer

  • Researchers must obtain voluntary informed consent from all participants (or parents/guardians for minors) before collecting any physiological data.
  • Participant safety must be prioritized through appropriate screening, monitoring during exercise, and immediate cessation of activity if adverse responses occur.
  • All data collected must be handled confidentially and stored securely to protect participant privacy throughout and after the investigation.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • Researchers must obtain voluntary informed consent from all participants (or parents/guardians for minors) before collecting any physiological data.
  • Participant safety must be prioritized through appropriate screening, monitoring during exercise, and immediate cessation of activity if adverse responses occur.
  • All data collected must be handled confidentially and stored securely to protect participant privacy throughout and after the investigation.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 404

A student wants to investigate how different body types respond to the same aerobic training protocol by measuring heart rate, ventilation rate, and perceived exertion. Analyse the ethical considerations related to body type classification and data presentation in this investigation.   (7 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer

  • Classification of participants by body type must use objective, scientifically-based criteria rather than subjective judgments to avoid stigmatisation or reinforcement of negative body stereotypes.
  • The language used in all aspects of the investigation (recruitment, protocols, and reporting) must be neutral and respectful, avoiding terms that could cause embarrassment or perpetuate weight bias.
  • Informed consent must clearly explain how body type will be determined and how this information will be used in the investigation to ensure participants understand what they are agreeing to.
  • Data presentation should focus on physiological responses rather than emphasising body type differences in ways that might reinforce stereotypes or cause participant discomfort when results are shared.
  • Group data should be used wherever possible to minimise identification of individuals, particularly for sensitive measures or when small numbers of participants represent specific body types.
  • Privacy during physical measurements related to body type determination (height, weight, circumference) must be strictly maintained to respect participant dignity.
  • Researchers should anticipate and mitigate potential psychological impacts of body type classification by emphasising the diversity of healthy body compositions and focusing on functional physiological responses rather than appearance.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • Classification of participants by body type must use objective, scientifically-based criteria rather than subjective judgments to avoid stigmatisation or reinforcement of negative body stereotypes.
  • The language used in all aspects of the investigation (recruitment, protocols, and reporting) must be neutral and respectful, avoiding terms that could cause embarrassment or perpetuate weight bias.
  • Informed consent must clearly explain how body type will be determined and how this information will be used in the investigation to ensure participants understand what they are agreeing to.
  • Data presentation should focus on physiological responses rather than emphasising body type differences in ways that might reinforce stereotypes or cause participant discomfort when results are shared.
  • Group data should be used wherever possible to minimise identification of individuals, particularly for sensitive measures or when small numbers of participants represent specific body types.
  • Privacy during physical measurements related to body type determination (height, weight, circumference) must be strictly maintained to respect participant dignity.
  • Researchers should anticipate and mitigate potential psychological impacts of body type classification by emphasising the diversity of healthy body compositions and focusing on functional physiological responses rather than appearance.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 403

Explain the importance of debriefing participants after they complete an investigation into physiological responses to aerobic training.   (5 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer

  • Debriefing fulfills the ethical obligation to educate participants by explaining the purpose, methods, and findings of the investigation in accessible language.
  • Sharing individual results privately with each participant respects their right to access their own physiological data and understand what it means for their health.
  • Debriefing provides an opportunity to identify and address any negative experiences, discomforts, or misconceptions participants may have had during the investigation.
  • Explaining how participants’ data contributed to the overall findings acknowledges their valuable contribution and demonstrates respect for their involvement.
  • Proper debriefing enhances the educational value of the investigation for participants, turning their participation into a meaningful learning experience about their own physiology.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • Debriefing fulfills the ethical obligation to educate participants by explaining the purpose, methods, and findings of the investigation in accessible language.
  • Sharing individual results privately with each participant respects their right to access their own physiological data and understand what it means for their health.
  • Debriefing provides an opportunity to identify and address any negative experiences, discomforts, or misconceptions participants may have had during the investigation.
  • Explaining how participants’ data contributed to the overall findings acknowledges their valuable contribution and demonstrates respect for their involvement.
  • Proper debriefing enhances the educational value of the investigation for participants, turning their participation into a meaningful learning experience about their own physiology.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 402

A student is planning an investigation into how aerobic training affects blood lactate levels, requiring finger-prick blood samples at rest, during exercise, and during recovery. Evaluate the ethical considerations that should be addressed in this investigation.   (6 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer

  • The invasive nature of blood sampling requires comprehensive informed consent that explicitly details the frequency, method, and potential discomfort of finger-prick procedures.
  • Participants must be screened for bleeding disorders, immunocompromised conditions, or needle phobias that would make blood sampling either physically or psychologically harmful.
  • The benefits of collecting direct blood lactate data must be weighed against the potential pain and anxiety caused by repeated finger-prick sampling during an aerobic session.
  • Proper training of those performing the sampling is an ethical requirement to minimise pain and prevent complications such as infection or excessive bleeding.
  • Appropriate biohazard procedures for handling blood samples must be strictly followed to protect both participants and researchers from potential contamination risks.
  • Participants’ right to withdraw must be emphasised, particularly during the actual sampling procedures if they experience more discomfort than anticipated.
  • A less invasive alternative method should be available for participants who consent to the investigation but experience excessive discomfort during initial blood sampling.
  • Privacy during blood collection and confidentiality of results are especially important with biological samples, requiring strict protocols for handling, storing, and eventually disposing of all blood-related materials.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • The invasive nature of blood sampling requires comprehensive informed consent that explicitly details the frequency, method, and potential discomfort of finger-prick procedures.
  • Participants must be screened for bleeding disorders, immunocompromised conditions, or needle phobias that would make blood sampling either physically or psychologically harmful.
  • The benefits of collecting direct blood lactate data must be weighed against the potential pain and anxiety caused by repeated finger-prick sampling during an aerobic session.
  • Proper training of those performing the sampling is an ethical requirement to minimise pain and prevent complications such as infection or excessive bleeding.
  • Appropriate biohazard procedures for handling blood samples must be strictly followed to protect both participants and researchers from potential contamination risks.
  • Participants’ right to withdraw must be emphasised, particularly during the actual sampling procedures if they experience more discomfort than anticipated.
  • A less invasive alternative method should be available for participants who consent to the investigation but experience excessive discomfort during initial blood sampling.
  • Privacy during blood collection and confidentiality of results are especially important with biological samples, requiring strict protocols for handling, storing, and eventually disposing of all blood-related materials.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 401

Analyse the ethical implications of using different methods to measure oxygen consumption during an investigation of aerobic training responses.   (6 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer

  • Direct measurement using metabolic carts with masks can provide accurate data but restrict normal breathing patterns, raising ethical concerns about participant comfort and potential anxiety during exercise.
  • Indirect estimation methods like heart rate monitoring are less invasive but provide less accurate data, creating an ethical dilemma between participant comfort and scientific validity.
  • For adolescent participants, the use of face masks for direct measurement may cause greater psychological discomfort than for adults, requiring additional sensitivity and clear explanation of procedures.
  • Researchers must carefully balance the scientific need for accurate physiological data against the ethical principle of minimizing participant discomfort or distress.
  • Pilot testing of measurement methods with a small group before full implementation allows researchers to identify unexpected discomforts or anxieties and modify protocols accordingly.
  • Providing participants with options between measurement methods where scientifically viable respects their autonomy while still enabling valuable data collection.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • Direct measurement using metabolic carts with masks can provide accurate data but restrict normal breathing patterns, raising ethical concerns about participant comfort and potential anxiety during exercise.
  • Indirect estimation methods like heart rate monitoring are less invasive but provide less accurate data, creating an ethical dilemma between participant comfort and scientific validity.
  • For adolescent participants, the use of face masks for direct measurement may cause greater psychological discomfort than for adults, requiring additional sensitivity and clear explanation of procedures.
  • Researchers must carefully balance the scientific need for accurate physiological data against the ethical principle of minimizing participant discomfort or distress.
  • Pilot testing of measurement methods with a small group before full implementation allows researchers to identify unexpected discomforts or anxieties and modify protocols accordingly.
  • Providing participants with options between measurement methods where scientifically viable respects their autonomy while still enabling valuable data collection.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 400

Explain ethical considerations when using a control group in an investigation of how aerobic training affects recovery heart rate.   (4 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer

  • The control group should not be disadvantaged by participation, which means they should receive an alternative appropriate activity rather than simply sitting idle.
  • All participants (both experimental and control groups) must receive full information about the group they are in and what their participation involves before giving consent.
  • If the aerobic training shows clear benefits during the investigation, there may be an ethical obligation to offer the control group similar training opportunities after the investigation concludes.
  • Random assignment to groups rather than selective placement ensures fairness and scientific validity while reducing potential bias.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • The control group should not be disadvantaged by participation, which means they should receive an alternative appropriate activity rather than simply sitting idle.
  • All participants (both experimental and control groups) must receive full information about the group they are in and what their participation involves before giving consent.
  • If the aerobic training shows clear benefits during the investigation, there may be an ethical obligation to offer the control group similar training opportunities after the investigation concludes.
  • Random assignment to groups rather than selective placement ensures fairness and scientific validity while reducing potential bias.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 399

Discuss the ethical considerations related to screening participants before their involvement in an investigation of physiological responses to moderate-intensity aerobic training.   (5 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer

  • Pre-participation health screening questionnaires are ethically essential to identify individuals with health conditions that might put them at risk during aerobic exercise.
  • Screening protocols must balance thoroughness with respect for privacy, asking only relevant health questions necessary to determine safe participation.
  • Exclusion of individuals based on screening results must be handled sensitively to avoid stigmatisation while prioritising participant safety.
  • Researchers have an ethical duty of care to ensure participants are physically capable of completing the aerobic training protocol without undue risk of adverse events.
  • Screening results must be kept confidential and stored securely with access limited to only those directly involved in participant safety decisions.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • Pre-participation health screening questionnaires are ethically essential to identify individuals with health conditions that might put them at risk during aerobic exercise.
  • Screening protocols must balance thoroughness with respect for privacy, asking only relevant health questions necessary to determine safe participation.
  • Exclusion of individuals based on screening results must be handled sensitively to avoid stigmatisation while prioritising participant safety.
  • Researchers have an ethical duty of care to ensure participants are physically capable of completing the aerobic training protocol without undue risk of adverse events.
  • Screening results must be kept confidential and stored securely with access limited to only those directly involved in participant safety decisions.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 398

Explain why maintaining confidentiality is an important ethical consideration when collecting physiological data during aerobic training investigations.   (4 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer

  • Physiological data such as heart rate, ventilation rate, and fitness levels are personal health information that participants have a right to keep private.
  • Breaches in confidentiality could lead to embarrassment or stigma if individual fitness levels or physiological responses are shared with others without permission.
  • Maintaining confidentiality builds trust with participants, encouraging honest participation and more reliable data collection during the investigation.
  • Practical measures to ensure confidentiality include using participant codes instead of names, storing data securely, and only presenting aggregated or de-identified results when sharing findings.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • Physiological data such as heart rate, ventilation rate, and fitness levels are personal health information that participants have a right to keep private.
  • Breaches in confidentiality could lead to embarrassment or stigma if individual fitness levels or physiological responses are shared with others without permission.
  • Maintaining confidentiality builds trust with participants, encouraging honest participation and more reliable data collection during the investigation.
  • Practical measures to ensure confidentiality include using participant codes instead of names, storing data securely, and only presenting aggregated or de-identified results when sharing findings.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 397

Outline TWO ethical considerations when investigating heart rate responses to aerobic training using student participants.   (3 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer – Any 2 of the following

  • Informed consent must be obtained from all participants (and parents/guardians if under 18) after explaining the purpose of the investigation, the heart rate monitoring procedures, and potential discomforts.
  • Confidentiality of personal health data must be maintained by using participant codes instead of names and securing all heart rate records in password-protected files.
  • Participants must have the right to withdraw from the investigation at any time without penalty or negative consequences.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer – Any 2 of the following

  • Informed consent must be obtained from all participants (and parents/guardians if under 18) after explaining the purpose of the investigation, the heart rate monitoring procedures, and potential discomforts.
  • Confidentiality of personal health data must be maintained by using participant codes instead of names and securing all heart rate records in password-protected files.
  • Participants must have the right to withdraw from the investigation at any time without penalty or negative consequences.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 396 MC

When collecting respiratory rate data during aerobic training investigation, which of the following represents appropriate ethical practice?

  1. Recording participants without their knowledge
  2. Sharing identified personal data with the whole class
  3. Allowing participants to withdraw at any time
  4. Requiring participants to complete the investigation regardless of discomfort
Show Answers Only

Show Worked Solution

Consider Option C: Allowing participants to withdraw at any time

  • Respecting participants’ right to withdraw at any time without penalty is a fundamental ethical principle in human research.

Other Options:

  • A is incorrect: Recording without knowledge violates informed consent principles.
  • B is incorrect: Sharing identified data breaches confidentiality.
  • D is incorrect: Requiring completion despite discomfort disrespects participant autonomy and wellbeing.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 395 MC

Which of the following would NOT typically be included in an informed consent form for an investigation into physiological responses to aerobic training?

  1. Disclosure of potential risks and discomforts
  2. Description of data collection procedures
  3. Guarantee of superior fitness results from participation
  4. Information about confidentiality of collected data
Show Answers Only

Show Worked Solution

Consider Option C: Guarantee of superior fitness results from participation

  • Promising specific fitness benefits would be misleading and unethical, as investigations cannot guarantee results to participants.

Other Options:

  • A is incorrect: Risk disclosure is an essential component of ethical informed consent.
  • B is incorrect: Procedure descriptions are necessary for participants to make informed decisions.
  • D is incorrect: Confidentiality information is a critical ethical component of informed consent.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 394 MC

A student plans to collect blood samples to measure lactate levels during an investigation of aerobic training responses. Which of the following represents the most significant ethical concern?

  1. The cost of blood sampling equipment
  2. The time required to analyse blood samples
  3. The need for specialised laboratory equipment
  4. The invasive nature of the procedure and participant discomfort
Show Answers Only

Show Worked Solution

Consider Option D: The invasive nature of the procedure and participant discomfort

  • The invasive nature of blood sampling raises ethical concerns about participant discomfort, potential harm, and requires careful consideration of risks versus benefits.

Other Options:

  • A is incorrect: Cost is a practical consideration, not primarily an ethical concern.
  • B is incorrect: Time requirements are logistical concerns, not ethical issues.
  • C is incorrect: Equipment needs are methodological considerations, not ethical concerns.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 393 MC

When investigating heart rate responses to aerobic training in classmates, which of the following is the most important ethical consideration?

  1. Getting permission from the school principal
  2. Obtaining informed consent from participants
  3. Using the latest heart rate monitoring technology
  4. Publishing the results in a school newsletter
Show Answers Only

Show Worked Solution

Consider Option B: Obtaining informed consent from participants

  • Obtaining informed consent ensures participants understand the purpose, procedures, potential risks, and their right to withdraw from the investigation.

Other Options:

  • A is incorrect: While administrative approval may be required, participant consent is the primary ethical consideration.
  • C is incorrect: Technology choice is a methodological decision, not a primary ethical consideration.
  • D is incorrect: Publication decisions come after data collection and are secondary to participant consent.

HMS, BM EQ-Bank 392

A student wants to investigate the relationship between heart rate and blood pressure responses during a 20-minute aerobic training session. Analyse suitable methods for collecting this data and explain potential challenges they might face.   (7 marks)

Show Answers Only

Sample Answer 

  • A continuous heart rate monitor with chest strap would provide uninterrupted heart rate data throughout the session without disturbing the exercise rhythm or intensity.
  • Blood pressure measurement using an automated cuff would require the participant to momentarily pause or reduce intensity to obtain readings, potentially affecting the natural physiological response.
  • Taking blood pressure readings at set intervals (pre-exercise, 5, 10, 15, 20 minutes, and recovery) would provide trend data without excessive disruption to the exercise session.
  • Body movement during exercise creates artifacts in both heart rate and blood pressure measurements, requiring careful technique and possibly repeated measurements for accuracy.
  • Environmental factors like temperature and humidity should be recorded as they influence both heart rate and blood pressure responses independently of exercise intensity.
  • Positioning of the blood pressure cuff must remain consistent to ensure comparable readings, which can be challenging during dynamic movements in aerobic training.
  • Synchronising the timing of heart rate and blood pressure data points is essential for valid correlation analysis, requiring precise coordination of measurement protocols.
Show Worked Solution

Sample Answer

  • A continuous heart rate monitor with chest strap would provide uninterrupted heart rate data throughout the session without disturbing the exercise rhythm or intensity.
  • Blood pressure measurement using an automated cuff would require the participant to momentarily pause or reduce intensity to obtain readings, potentially affecting the natural physiological response.
  • Taking blood pressure readings at set intervals (pre-exercise, 5, 10, 15, 20 minutes, and recovery) would provide trend data without excessive disruption to the exercise session.
  • Body movement during exercise creates artifacts in both heart rate and blood pressure measurements, requiring careful technique and possibly repeated measurements for accuracy.
  • Environmental factors like temperature and humidity should be recorded as they influence both heart rate and blood pressure responses independently of exercise intensity.
  • Positioning of the blood pressure cuff must remain consistent to ensure comparable readings, which can be challenging during dynamic movements in aerobic training.
  • Synchronising the timing of heart rate and blood pressure data points is essential for valid correlation analysis, requiring precise coordination of measurement protocols.